A large-scale analysis of over five million developmental assessments conducted across Israel reveals that while overall developmental milestone failure rates showed only a mild upward trend between 2019 and 2023, disparities tied to specific maternal characteristics widened significantly during periods of national disruption. The study, which utilized data from the national Tipat Halav Maternal and Child Health Clinics system, monitored 1,158,536 unique children to identify trends in developmental attainment. By evaluating language, social, gross motor, and fine motor skills, researchers aimed to determine how sociodemographic factors influenced developmental outcomes against a backdrop of the COVID-19 pandemic and the escalation of war in late 2023. These findings indicate that while the overall population health trajectory remained relatively stable, specific subpopulations, particularly those with mothers facing structural vulnerabilities, experienced increasing difficulties in meeting key developmental milestones.
The study population was extensive, encompassing children who attended 494 clinics across Israel between October 2018 and September 2024. Developmental assessments were tracked using a standardized scale that defined failure as the inability to attain a milestone by the age at which 95 percent of the population successfully acquires it. To maintain consistency and account for significant procedural changes, researchers performed separate analyses for the periods of 2019 through early 2023 and the period following a Ministry of Health policy update in March 2023. This methodological decision was critical, as the updated guidelines introduced new milestones and modified assessment schedules, which could have otherwise skewed the interpretation of failure rates. Despite these adjustments, the research provides a comprehensive view of how systemic strain—such as the irregular clinic visits and resident evacuations caused by the 2023 conflict—affected the accuracy and continuity of developmental surveillance.
Results from the 2019 to 2023 period demonstrated a mild increase in milestone failure rates across all four developmental domains. The language domain consistently recorded the highest failure percentages throughout the study, at 5.4 percent in 2019 and 5.51 percent in 2023. Other domains followed similar, albeit less dramatic, patterns. A notable shift in the findings occurred regarding parental concern, which rose steadily from 3.65 percent in 2019 to 3.94 percent in 2024. This increase reversed a downward trend observed in previous years, suggesting that parental awareness of potential developmental challenges has intensified, even as objective failure rates displayed complexity following the 2023 policy shift. The authors noted that parental concern was most frequently expressed by mothers born in the Former Soviet Union, contrasting with lower levels of reported concern in other ethnic groups despite varying objective failure rates.
A primary focus of the research was the relationship between maternal characteristics and child developmental outcomes. Throughout the reporting period, children of mothers with favorable socioeconomic conditions—including higher education, stable employment, and supportive marital statuses—consistently exhibited the lowest rates of milestone non-attainment. Conversely, disparities became markedly more pronounced between 2019 and 2023 for children whose mothers possessed lower levels of education, were unemployed, or were divorced. These gaps in development, particularly in the language and social domains, widened further in 2024. For instance, children born to mothers with only elementary education saw their failure rates in language milestones rise from 7.7 percent in 2019 to 9.5 percent in 2024, whereas failure rates among children of academically educated mothers remained significantly lower and more stable by comparison.
While maternal-level characteristics were strongly associated with elevated developmental risk, the study highlighted a different trend regarding socioeconomic and ethnic backgrounds. In a departure from the widening gaps seen with individual maternal factors, disparities related to area-level socioeconomic status and ethnicity remained relatively stable or, in some instances, narrowed over the study period. Children from the highest socioeconomic clusters consistently maintained the lowest failure rates, yet this advantage did not expand over time. Similarly, ethnic and religious subgroups showed a gradual convergence in failure rates. This pattern is particularly intriguing given that historical trends often emphasize the persistence of socioeconomic gradients in early childhood development. Researchers suggest that these findings might reflect the impact of targeted community interventions or improved service access, although the current observational design cannot confirm causality for these stabilizing effects.
The longitudinal data also captured interesting variations across different community contexts, such as the Haredi population. Parents residing in non-Haredi areas consistently reported higher levels of developmental concern compared to their counterparts in Haredi regions. In terms of objective outcomes, the study found a widening gap in language and social development between children in Haredi and non-Haredi communities, with non-Haredi children experiencing a slight increase in failure rates in 2024. Conversely, children from Haredi backgrounds showed higher failure rates in fine and gross motor domains throughout most of the study years. These distinctions emphasize the role that local social structures, parental reporting habits, and access to service frameworks play in both the perception and measurement of child developmental milestones.
Sex-based differences in developmental attainment also persisted in the current findings. Males were more likely than females to fail milestones across all assessed domains, with the largest disparity found in the language domain. In 2024, the failure rate for males in the language domain reached 6.2 percent, compared to 3.8 percent for females. These consistent results, which align with previous national reports, underscore the potential need for sex-specific developmental assessment scales, as the current universal evaluation methods might not fully capture the distinct developmental trajectories of boys and girls. Furthermore, the analysis by maternal age confirmed that children of older mothers—those aged 40 and above—and adolescent mothers showed elevated risks of unmet milestones, especially within the social and language categories during the 2023–2024 period.
The researchers acknowledged several limitations in their study, most notably the exclusion of approximately 30 percent of children who attend non-Ministry of Health clinics. While validation analyses suggest the study cohort remains broadly representative of the national population, the researchers highlighted that geographic and cultural variability in assessment practices could introduce inconsistencies. Additionally, the reliance on area-level metrics for socioeconomic status and Haredi population density rather than individual-level data means that certain nuances of family experience may remain uncaptured. Caregiver health literacy and the quality of communication between clinic staff and parents are also influential factors that may have shaped the data, especially across diverse demographic groups.
Contextual shocks, particularly the COVID-19 pandemic and the outbreak of war in October 2023, were identified as significant contributors to the observed widening of developmental gaps. These events caused repeated disruptions to routine preventive health services, forced evacuations of residents, and necessitated an increased reliance on parental reporting rather than direct observation by clinical staff. The authors noted that these disruptions disproportionately affected families with fewer resources, thereby magnifying existing inequalities. The expansion of these gaps in 2024 is interpreted by the study team as a clear signal that maternal-level risk factors are particularly sensitive to systemic strain, necessitating a more robust and responsive developmental surveillance system that can withstand periods of national crisis.
In conclusion, the findings emphasize that developmental disparities in early childhood are dynamic and highly sensitive to the social and situational context of the families being served. The widening of gaps linked to maternal education, marital status, and age during recent periods of conflict underscores the importance of focusing on maternal support as a component of child health equity. While socioeconomic and ethnic disparities showed unexpected stability, the overall evidence points to a critical need for equity-oriented developmental services. Strategies such as enhanced outreach to high-risk families, improved caregiver communication, and consistent referral pathways remain essential. By maintaining a universal standard for surveillance while simultaneously tailoring the intensity of follow-up care to identified needs, decision-makers in health, welfare, and education can better support equitable developmental outcomes for children across Israel, even in times of significant uncertainty.
Subject of Research: Trends in developmental milestone attainment among Israeli children (2019–2024)
Article Title: Trends in developmental milestone attainment among Israeli children between 2019 and 2024
Article References: Girshovitz, I., Amit, G., Goldshtein, I., Akiva, P., Milo, D. L., Zimmerman, D. R., Baruch, R., Avgil Tsadok, M., & Sadaka, Y. (2026). Trends in developmental milestone attainment among Israeli children between 2019 and 2024. Israel Journal of Health Policy Research, 15(1), Article 28. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13584-026-00771-2
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13584-026-00771-2
Keywords: Child Development, Developmental Milestones, Israel, Public Health, Maternal Education, Pediatric Health, Socioeconomic Disparities, COVID-19 Pandemic, War, Israel Journal of Health Policy Research, Early Childhood Development, Developmental Surveillance, Tipat Halav, Maternal Characteristics, Health Equity, Pediatric Outcomes

