Volume-controlled mechanical ventilation delivered significantly higher expiratory tidal volumes and reduced volume deficits compared with manual bag-valve-device ventilation when utilizing the newly redesigned laryngeal tube evo during continuous mechanical chest compressions, according to a prospective randomized investigation conducted in Thiel-embalmed human body donors and published in the Journal of Anesthesia, Analgesia and Critical Care.
Researchers examined expiratory tidal volume as the primary efficacy endpoint across five adult human body donors undergoing standardized resuscitation. Across the recorded trials, volume-controlled mechanical ventilation achieved a mean expiratory tidal volume of 142.93 ± 115.05 milliliters compared to 91.73 ± 66.3 milliliters observed during manual bag-valve-device ventilation. Linear mixed-effects regression models with random intercepts revealed that volume-controlled ventilation generated a statistically significant mean increase of 50.27 milliliters in expiratory tidal volume (95% confidence interval: 7.56 to 92.97; p = 0.02) and an increase of 0.8 milliliters per kilogram of body weight (95% confidence interval: 0.05 to 1.56; p = 0.04).
The comparative analysis documented substantial differences in ventilation pressures, rate stability, and volume deficits between the two delivery modes. Volume-controlled ventilation generated higher mean airway pressures, displaying a regression difference of 5.23 mbar (95% confidence interval: 4.0 to 6.47; p < 0.001), as well as higher plateau pressures with a difference of 10.36 mbar (95% confidence interval: 8.08 to 12.64; p < 0.001). Conversely, the volume-controlled technique reduced the delta tidal volume—defined as the difference between ideal tidal volume calculated via Broca’s formula and measured expiratory tidal volume—by -50.3 milliliters (95% confidence interval: -93 to -7.59; p = 0.02) and demonstrated a lower respiratory rate by -10.83 breaths per minute (95% confidence interval: -17.29 to -4.36; p = 0.001) relative to manual bag-valve delivery.
Despite the higher average volumes achieved through volume-controlled ventilation, the protocol revealed pronounced interindividual variability among the five body donors when evaluating sufficient ventilation, defined as achieving an expiratory tidal volume exceeding a dead space threshold of 2 milliliters per kilogram of body weight. Only one donor (20 percent) achieved sufficient ventilation across all evaluated ventilation modes. Three donors could only be adequately ventilated using a single technique, with 40 percent (two donors) successfully ventilated solely via volume-controlled mechanical ventilation and 20 percent (one donor) successfully ventilated exclusively through bag-valve-device delivery. Notably, one donor (20 percent) could not be sufficiently ventilated by either technique, highlighting unpredictable airway behavior during continuous chest compressions.
Intra-arrest ventilation remains essential for re-oxygenation and carbon dioxide elimination once advanced cardiovascular life support continues following layperson compression-only cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Supraglottic airway devices are widely utilized worldwide by emergency medical personnel because they can be positioned rapidly without interrupting continuous chest compressions, particularly when emergency providers encounter low tracheal intubation success rates. While European Resuscitation Council guidelines recommend the preferred use of an i-gel laryngeal mask over traditional laryngeal tubes based on favorable placement success and complication profiles, the clinical performance of the newly modified laryngeal tube evo had not previously been established under intra-arrest conditions.
The laryngeal tube evo represents a complete second-generation redesign of the established LTS-D airway platform manufactured by VBM Medizintechnik. Engineered from softer, more pliable materials than its predecessor, the evo variant incorporates an altered geometry intended to conform closely to the anatomical contours of relaxed pharyngeal structures and facilitate smoother placement. The device features an updated proximal cuff designed to enhance seal pressure against the oropharynx while maintaining pressures below or equal to 60 cmH2O, alongside a distal cuff intended to seal the upper esophageal entrance. Additionally, the interior architecture includes an expanded ventilation lumen and an integrated distal ramp engineered to facilitate fiberoptic-guided tracheal intubation directly through the tube.
Conducted at the Institute of Anatomy of Ruhr University Bochum in collaboration with the Clinical-Anatomical Research and Training Center following ethical approval and registration in the German Clinical Trials Register (DRKS00037836), the trial enrolled five adult donors preserved using the Thiel embalming method. Thiel preservation was specifically selected because it preserves the compliance and biomechanical characteristics of living lung tissue more effectively than conventional fixation methods. Prior to testing, cadavers underwent external anatomical examinations, calculation of ideal body weight via Broca’s formula, baseline tracheal intubation to verify anatomy and clear secretions via bronchoscopy, and four minutes of standardized lung recruitment using pressure-controlled ventilation at an inspiratory pressure of 35 mbar and positive end-expiratory pressure of 12 mbar.
Following initial lung recruitment and extubation, the laryngeal tube evo was inserted according to a randomized sequence, with cuff pressures standardized to 40 cmH2O and proper positioning confirmed through bronchoscopy. Mechanical cardiopulmonary resuscitation was applied continuously using a Corpuls-CPR automated chest compression machine set to a compression rate of 100 per minute and a depth of 5.5 centimeters. Between experimental conditions, researchers performed ultrasonographic examinations to detect potential pneumothoraces, with protocol provisions to place Bülau chest drainage tubes if required. For each condition, five recruitment breaths were administered via a MEDUTrigger before four minutes of intra-arrest ventilation took place.
Manual bag-valve-device ventilation was administered by experienced specialist anesthesiologists with preclinical emergency backgrounds targeting a respiratory rate of 10 breaths per minute. Measurement was enabled by modifying a MEDUMAT Standard2 system, placing FlowCheck flow sensors, carbon dioxide adapters, and pressure monitoring lines directly between the resuscitator bag and the airway device. Volume-controlled ventilation was delivered using a MEDUVENT mechanical ventilator set to deliver 7 milliliters per kilogram of body weight at 10 breaths per minute, with positive end-expiratory pressure maintained at 3 mbar and a peak airway pressure limit of 40 mbar. Manual delivery exhibited wide variations in delivered volumes and higher respiratory rates, reflecting known clinical vulnerabilities where manual bag compression without real-time volume feedback risks hypoventilation or unintended hyperventilation.
The researchers highlighted that chest compressions induce substantial intrathoracic pressure gradients and reverse airflow phenomena during both inspiratory and expiratory phases, creating significant leaks around supraglottic airway seals. The observed loss of effective tidal volume indicates that applied ventilator settings do not reliably guarantee adequate alveolar ventilation during mechanical chest compressions. In light of these unpredictable air leaks and the finding that manual bag-valve-device ventilation cannot reliably guarantee rescue tidal volumes exceeding dead space in every subject, the authors underscored current European Resuscitation Council guidelines recommending a transition to synchronous 30:2 ventilation whenever rescuers suspect insufficient ventilation or substantial leakage around a supraglottic airway.
Several procedural constraints contextualize the findings, beginning with the small cohort of five Thiel-embalmed body donors, which limits statistical generalizability. Furthermore, each donor underwent an aggregate resuscitation protocol of approximately 76 minutes across multiple airway devices and ventilation modes due to the scarce availability of Thiel-fixed specimens, potentially altering tissue properties over time despite randomization. The investigators also adhered to a conservative peak pressure ceiling of 40 mbar and a cuff pressure of 40 cmH2O to ensure consistency across devices, whereas modern guidelines permit pressure limits up to 60 to 70 cmH2O and the manufacturer allows cuff inflation up to 60 cmH2O. Finally, while Thiel preservation provides pliable tissue for laboratory evaluation, cadaveric mechanics may differ from living human physiology during active out-of-hospital cardiac arrest.
Subject of Research: Comparison of volume-controlled and bag-valve-device ventilation using the laryngeal tube evo during mechanical chest compressions in body donors
Article Title: Comparison of bag-valve-device ventilation and volume-controlled ventilation with laryngeal tube evo in intra-arrest ventilation—a prospective randomized study in human body donors
Article References: Falk, C. C., Brand-Saberi, B., Förster, E., Gelashvili, T., Genzwürker, H., Hinkelbein, J., Hoyer, A., Thomasseck, A., Trenkel, J., Tiesmeier, J., Kolaparambil Varghese, L. J., & Jansen, G. (2026). Comparison of bag-valve-device ventilation and volume-controlled ventilation with laryngeal tube evo in intra-arrest ventilation—a prospective randomized study in human body donors. Journal of Anesthesia, Analgesia and Critical Care, 6(1), Article 117. https://doi.org/10.1186/s44158-026-00458-9
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s44158-026-00458-9
Keywords: intra-arrest ventilation, laryngeal tube evo, volume-controlled ventilation, bag-valve-device ventilation, mechanical cardiopulmonary resuscitation, supraglottic airway device, expiratory tidal volume, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, cadaver study, Thiel-embalmed body donors, emergency airway management, plateau pressure, mean airway pressure, chest compressions, respiratory rate, dead space volume

