Hospital quality managers navigating case-based exclusions within Israel’s National Program for Quality Indicators experience systemic gaps in structured onboarding, feedback from central health authorities, and formal recognition for clinical advocacy, according to a qualitative study published in the Israel Journal of Health Policy Research. The research, which analyzed in-depth phenomenological interviews with quality managers across general, geriatric, and psychiatric medical centers, revealed that while the individual appeals track serves as a vital safeguard against rigid performance metrics, professionals predominantly learn the submission process through informal trial and error rather than standardized training or official administrative guidance. Although national indicator frameworks are designed to monitor clinical performance and foster organizational accountability, standard metrics often fail to accommodate atypical clinical presentations, delayed patient arrivals, or complex comorbidities. To prevent misclassifying clinically appropriate care as substandard performance, the appeals mechanism allows institutions to petition for patient exclusions when target deviations stem from circumstances beyond hospital control, yet managers report that procedural ambiguities and limited feedback diminish its operational efficacy.
Healthcare performance monitoring has expanded across international health systems to benchmark patient safety and clinical effectiveness, establishing standardized baselines to track institutional variation. However, rigid adherence to unadjusted benchmarks can generate unintended distortions, including provider avoidance of complex patients, disproportionate attention to measured metrics over broader clinical needs, and documentation adjustments aimed solely at hitting numerical targets. To reconcile standardized oversight with clinical reality, systems like the United Kingdom’s Quality and Outcomes Framework have incorporated exception reporting for patient refusals or contraindications, while American programs permit specific case-level exclusions. In 2021, the Israeli National Program for Quality Indicators introduced an individual appeals track across general, geriatric, and psychiatric hospitals to bolster methodological fairness and transparency. Operating on a quarterly reporting cycle, quality managers review noncompliant cases, record formal clinical justifications within a designated exceptions sheet in official submission files, and submit requests to the Ministry of Health, which reviews the clinical context before deciding whether to remove disputed cases from indicator denominator calculations.
To evaluate how this exception mechanism functions three years after its national rollout, researchers conducted a qualitative phenomenological study examining the lived experiences of ten hospital quality managers. The investigators recruited participants from diverse institutional profiles, comprising six managers from general hospitals with mixed medical, geriatric, or psychiatric departments, two managers from dedicated geriatric facilities, and two from dedicated psychiatric hospitals. Participating managers represented varied geographic regions and facility sizes, meeting the study inclusion requirement of at least one year of experience in their managerial quality role. Among the ten interviewees, professional healthcare experience spanned between 13 and 35 years, with tenure in their specific quality management positions ranging from 1 to 14 years. Nine participants were registered nurses holding master’s degrees, one was a registered nurse with a bachelor’s degree, and five had completed advanced certification in quality assurance. Seven managers were born in Israel and three had immigrated from the former Soviet Union, with eight identifying ethnically as Jewish and two as Arab.
The methodological framework combined semi-structured, one-time interviews conducted over Zoom during 2024, each lasting between 30 and 50 minutes, with iterative data analysis. Two researchers carried out the interviews using a standardized guide supplemented by clarification prompts to explore participants’ daily routines, administrative challenges, and institutional interactions. All sessions were audio-recorded, anonymized, and transcribed before undergoing thematic, textual, and content analysis. To enhance analytical rigor and achieve methodological triangulation, the investigative team paired human thematic interpretation with automated text processing via Transcriptor AI, an artificial intelligence software utilized for keyword extraction, thematic clustering, and sentiment analysis. Ethical approval was granted by the Institutional Review Board of Ramat Gan Academic College under approval number 1013, with all participants providing written informed consent prior to data collection.
The study’s first major finding centered on substantial knowledge and familiarity gaps surrounding the appeals mechanism and its official documentation. Every interviewed manager recognized the appeals track as a routine quarterly obligation, acknowledging an enduring gray area where clinical cases fail formal indicator thresholds yet represent legitimate deviations outside clinical control. Nevertheless, managers reported an absence of structured onboarding regarding how to formulate and justify submissions. Successive managers relied on handover periods from predecessors that ranged from two weeks to an entire year, though several noted that handovers contained no active appeal cases. Multiple managers described navigating the track entirely through unguided trial and error, leading junior professionals to believe that valid appeals were missed during their early tenure while other submissions lacked necessary clinical grounding. Experience gradually increased appeal submission volumes and Ministry approval rates, but familiarity with formal ministerial guidelines remained remarkably scarce: only one manager was well acquainted with the published instructions, three believed no guidelines existed, and six knew of them but could not recall their content.
Compounding this lack of operational preparation was widespread obscurity regarding Ministry of Health review procedures. While the appeals trajectory follows a hierarchical reporting pathway from hospital submission to ministerial determination, eight of the ten managers could not identify who evaluates their clinical justifications or what specific criteria govern approval decisions. Only two participants demonstrated an understanding of ministerial decision-making, while others presumed decisions rested with regional supervising nurses or remained entirely uncertain about who reviewed their documentation. The researchers observed that while the Ministry of Health had distributed official guidelines and illustrative case examples in 2021, the absence of periodic refresher courses or standardized curriculum modules left managers dependent on informal, fragmented knowledge networks, demonstrating that publishing administrative directives without active dissemination fails to secure consistent operational adoption across hospital networks.
Interactions among stakeholders formed the second primary theme, revealing a bifurcated communication landscape characterized by close local collaboration alongside distant national oversight. Within hospitals, quality managers reported robust cooperation with internal clinicians, routinely consulting attending physicians and ward nurses to draft appeals collaboratively. Furthermore, six managers highlighted communication with Ministry of Health supervising nurses as a vital, highly supportive resource for clarifying case nuances prior to submission. However, interactions with executive tiers of the Ministry showed pronounced divergence. Six managers viewed the appeals track as a constructive feedback channel that demonstrated ministerial flexibility and made field clinicians feel heard. Conversely, four managers experienced significant administrative alienation, perceiving that ministerial reviewers viewed submissions with suspicion as attempts to manipulate quality scores through excessive bureaucratic scrutiny.
Communication deficits extended horizontally across peer medical centers, highlighting an absence of inter-institutional learning. Every interviewed manager reported being unaware of appeals practices and submission trends in other hospitals. Although all participants belonged to a nationwide hospital quality forum on WhatsApp, discussions regarding individual appeal strategies or benchmark exceptions never took place within the group. Managers characterized the appeals landscape as an isolated environment devoid of cross-hospital discourse, expressing a strong desire for structured professional forums, joint conferences, and inter-institutional workshops. Participants argued that direct dialogue with ministerial decision-makers—replacing isolated electronic mail exchanges—would enable hospital quality personnel to contribute frontline clinical expertise toward refining indicator definitions and standardizing exception criteria, thereby transforming routine data submission into an evidence-based partnership grounded in operational realities.
The third core theme identified by the investigators involved quality managers’ profound expectations for professional acknowledgment from health authorities. Managers emphasized that their position entails a delicate dual representation, acting simultaneously as institutional advocates conveying frontline clinical challenges to regulators and as regulatory representatives enforcing national benchmarks among hospital medical staff. In this intermediary capacity, submitting appeals serves not merely as an administrative task, but as a crucial mechanism to validate the dedication of bedside clinicians whose extensive care efforts might otherwise be penalized by unyielding quantitative algorithms.
The emotional impact of ministerial determinations significantly influenced managers’ professional self-worth and motivation. When the Ministry of Health accepted an appeal, managers experienced personal satisfaction, internal closure, and validation that their institutional diligence was acknowledged. In sharp contrast, rejections elicited intense frustration and demoralization, causing managers to feel reduced to administrative coders completing tick-box exercises rather than recognized clinical specialists. Interviewees reported that denied appeals rarely included personalized explanatory feedback, reinforcing impressions of arbitrary evaluation. Drawing on organizational literature regarding meaningful recognition, the study authors highlighted that professional validation requires deliberate, transparent practices that align employee efforts with overarching institutional goals.
Evaluating the broader implications of exception reporting, the authors discussed how the structural impact of appeals varies across different quality metrics. In clinical indicators governed by small patient denominators or rare medical events, adding or subtracting a single patient case drastically alters calculated institutional compliance rates. For high-volume clinical indicators, the statistical influence of isolated appeals remains negligible. Despite this limited quantitative effect in large patient cohorts, managers affirmed that the appeals process remains indispensable for addressing atypical care episodes and preserving clinician trust in national performance assessments. Although assembling clinical documentation imposes notable administrative workloads, maintaining a transparent exception track reinforces the legitimacy of national oversight programs by ensuring that quality assessments accommodate real-world clinical discretion rather than rigid metric adherence.
The authors identified several methodological limitations inherent in their research design that warrant measured interpretation. The investigation relied exclusively on the subjective accounts of hospital quality managers, excluding the perspectives of ministerial reviewers, supervising nurses, and frontline hospital physicians. Furthermore, the qualitative phenomenological approach is susceptible to participant recall bias and personal interpretation, while the sample size of ten managers from selected institutions limits direct generalizability across all hospital contexts. The researchers also noted that specific cultural and organizational dynamics within the Israeli healthcare framework may influence operational interactions differently than in other national health systems. To address these systemic weaknesses, the authors recommended institutionalizing structured onboarding curricula, formal mentorship initiatives, transparent vertical feedback loops, and inter-hospital educational forums, thereby converting the appeals track from an isolated administrative burden into a robust platform for continuous healthcare quality improvement.
Subject of Research: Hospital quality managers’ experiences with exception appeals in national quality indicator programs
Article Title: From exception to insight: a phenomenological study of quality managers’ perspectives on the individual appeals in the National Healthcare Quality Program
Article References: Awawdi, K., Maoz, E., Friedensohn, L., & Erlich-Shoham, Y. (2026). From exception to insight: a phenomenological study of quality managers’ perspectives on the individual appeals in the National Healthcare Quality Program. Israel Journal of Health Policy Research, 15(1), Article 24. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13584-026-00766-z
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13584-026-00766-z
Keywords: Quality Managers, National Quality Indicators, Healthcare Quality, Individual Appeals, Hospital Performance, Qualitative Research, Phenomenology, Exception Reporting, Ministry of Health, Clinical Governance, Performance Metrics, Onboarding Programs, Professional Recognition, Israel Journal of Health Policy Research, Health Policy, Administrative Burden, Continuous Quality Improvement

