paradoxical-leadership-drives-radical-employee-creativity-through-workplace-identity-and-engagement
Paradoxical Leadership Drives Radical Employee Creativity Through Workplace Identity and Engagement

Paradoxical Leadership Drives Radical Employee Creativity Through Workplace Identity and Engagement

A multi-industry study examining corporate teams in mainland China reveals that paradoxical leadership behavior significantly enhances employees’ radical creativity by simultaneously fostering their creative role identity and elevating their creative work engagement. Radical creativity involves the generation of groundbreaking organizational ideas that depart substantially from established practices, frameworks, and institutional knowledge systems, creating notable strategic advantages alongside substantial operational risks. Investigating how organizational leaders navigate competing workplace demands, researchers Wei Zhang and Kanaththa Kankanamalage Sachith Prabash Perera applied sensemaking theory to evaluate how supervisory cues guide employees through ambiguity toward novel problem-solving.

The conceptual framework underpinning this research relies on sensemaking theory to explain how followers interpret and resolve contradictory leadership signals in demanding environments. In modern enterprises navigating intense competition, rapid technological advancements, and economic volatility, organizations increasingly depend on radical innovations rather than incremental product refinements. According to sensemaking principles, when individuals encounter ambiguous organizational cues, they extract salient environmental signals to build coherent explanatory models, reconciling discrepancies by actively revising their own assumptions and functional interpretations. Paradoxical leadership acts as an external catalyst for this meaning-making cycle by presenting interconnected yet competing behavioral expectations. Rather than forcing workers into a rigid either-or dilemma, paradoxical managers prompt employees to reconsider prevailing work boundaries, embrace complex cognitive perspectives, and reconstruct their day-to-day functional duties, thereby establishing the intellectual foundation necessary for unconventional, breakthrough creative performance across operational units.

To evaluate these theoretical mechanisms empirically, the investigators executed a time-lagged, multi-source survey design specifically structured to mitigate common method bias across technical teams. The sample was drawn from technology-intensive sectors where radical creativity is critical for corporate survival, including Internet technology, biomedicine, new energy, and real estate development. Data collection occurred across two distinct intervals separated by a two-week lag. Two weeks later, at Time 2, participating team leaders formally evaluated the radical creativity demonstrated by their individual subordinates, while team members completed self-report instruments measuring their creative role identity and creative work engagement. This rigorous procedure yielded a final, fully matched analytical sample of eighty-four distinct teams comprising four hundred nineteen employees and eighty-four supervisors.

Demographic profiling of the study cohort provided substantial context regarding the professional background and educational attainment of the organizational participants. Among the eighty-four participating team leaders, men accounted for 53.6 percent of the group, with an average chronological age of 37.54 years and an average organizational tenure of 5.68 years, while exactly half held a bachelor’s degree or higher educational credential. Within the subordinate sample of four hundred nineteen technical professionals, men represented 49.9 percent, exhibiting a mean age of 30.76 years and an average organizational tenure of 3.64 years. Furthermore, 52.3 percent of participating team members possessed at least a bachelor’s level education.

The empirical methodology utilized validated, mature psychometric measurement scales to quantify every organizational construct with high reliability and discriminant validity. Paradoxical leadership was evaluated by subordinates using a twenty-two-item instrument on a five-point Likert scale, measuring supervisory behaviors such as assigning equal workloads while adapting to individual strengths, achieving an internal consistency Cronbach’s alpha of 0.92. Subordinates’ radical creativity was evaluated by direct supervisors through a three-item, seven-point instrument assessing the generation of fundamentally new working methodologies, yielding an alpha coefficient of 0.81. Creative role identity was measured among subordinates via a three-item, seven-point scale capturing how central creative accomplishment is to their self-concept, demonstrating an alpha of 0.84. Creative work engagement was gauged using a nine-item instrument adapted to capture vigor, dedication, and absorption in creative tasks, demonstrating an alpha of 0.87. Finally, leaders rated perceived organizational valuing of creativity across six items on a seven-point scale, displaying an alpha of 0.87.

Statistical evaluation commenced with confirmatory factor analysis conducted in Mplus 8.3 to substantiate the structural distinctiveness of the primary survey variables. The hypothesized five-factor baseline model—comprising paradoxical leadership, creative role identity, creative work engagement, perceived organizational valuing of creativity, and radical creativity—demonstrated superior goodness-of-fit indices relative to alternative measurement structures, yielding a chi-square of 255.60 with 160 degrees of freedom, a chi-square ratio of 1.60, a comparative fit index of 0.97, a Tucker-Lewis index of 0.97, a root mean square error of approximation of 0.04, and a standardized root mean square residual of 0.03. Subsequent correlation analyses performed in R revealed statistically significant positive associations across all hypothesized relationships. Paradoxical leadership correlated positively with creative role identity, creative work engagement, and radical creativity.

Direct hypothesis testing and stepwise regression confirmed the substantial positive impact of paradoxical leadership practices upon subordinates’ radical creative output. To examine indirect pathways, the researchers executed bootstrapping procedures employing 10,000 resamples to generate bias-corrected 95 percent confidence intervals. The statistical indirect effect of paradoxical leadership on radical creativity via creative role identity reached 0.240 with a standard error of 0.048 and a confidence interval spanning 0.151 to 0.340. Similarly, the indirect effect operating through creative work engagement was 0.317 with a standard error of 0.056 and a confidence interval between 0.210 and 0.431. Because neither interval included zero, both individual mediating pathways were fully confirmed.

Expanding the structural analysis into sequential mediation, the researchers tested whether creative role identity and creative work engagement operate sequentially to transmit supervisory influence. Drawing upon sensemaking mechanics, the investigators hypothesized that paradoxical leaders initially stimulate subordinates to construct a heightened creative role identity, which subsequently elevates personal vigor, dedication, and cognitive absorption in workplace innovation. When both creative role identity and creative work engagement were entered simultaneously into the regression model, the serial mediation pathway linking paradoxical leadership to radical creativity remained statistically significant, validating Hypothesis 4. This chain effect demonstrates that paradoxical supervisory cues motivate employees to redefine their professional identity around creative problem-solving first; this validated internal identity subsequently channels continuous energetic focus into exploratory tasks, ultimately generating the complex, disruptive insights that constitute radical workplace innovation within corporate research and operational settings.

The study also thoroughly assessed the moderating boundary condition introduced by perceived organizational valuing of creativity, testing whether broader corporate climate amplifies these leadership effects. Moderated regression models demonstrated that the statistical interaction between paradoxical leadership and perceived organizational valuing of creativity positively predicted both creative role identity and creative work engagement. Conditional indirect effect analyses revealed that under high organizational appreciation for creativity, paradoxical leadership exerted a strong indirect effect on radical creativity through creative role identity of 0.388, which decreased to 0.235 at medium valuing and became statistically non-significant at low valuing levels. When examining creative work engagement, the indirect effect remained significant across all tiers, moving from 0.394 under high valuing down to 0.314 at medium and 0.234 at low valuing. Furthermore, the overall serial mediation chain was significantly moderated by organizational valuing at medium and high levels, confirming that supportive corporate cultures provide the necessary psychological safety net for paradoxical leadership to operate optimally.

Despite these extensive findings, the authors highlighted important methodological boundaries and outlined directions for ongoing organizational inquiry. Second, although the research gathered multi-wave, time-lagged data across two distinct collection periods, paradoxical leadership was operationalized as a static construct rather than capturing its continuous dynamic adjustments across changing workplace episodes over extended time horizons. Third, radical creativity was measured through subjective managerial appraisals rather than objective metrics, introducing potential supervisory evaluation biases. Consequently, future investigations should employ objective creative metrics and longitudinal dynamic tracking to examine how paradoxical leadership influences follower cognition across diverse global industries.

Subject of Research: Organizational behavior research examining paradoxical leadership mechanisms and employee radical creativity under sensemaking theory

Article Title: The role of paradoxical leadership in stimulating employees’ radical creativity: a perspective of sensemaking theory

Article References: Zhang, W., & Perera, K. K. S. P. (2026). The role of paradoxical leadership in stimulating employees’ radical creativity: a perspective of sensemaking theory. Management System Engineering, 5(1), Article 14. https://doi.org/10.1007/s44176-026-00070-9

Image Credits: AI Generated

DOI: 10.1007/s44176-026-00070-9

Keywords: paradoxical leadership, radical creativity, sensemaking theory, creative role identity, creative work engagement, perceived organizational valuing of creativity, organizational behavior, dual-wave survey, structural equation modeling, confirmatory factor analysis, workplace psychology, employee innovation, leadership behavior, serial mediation, moderated mediation, technology enterprises, supervisory evaluation