A new study conducted in the coastal waters of the Florida Keys, USA, has provided critical insights into how reef-associated fishes utilize the complex seascape during their formative sub-adult life stages. Researchers examined five common, habitat-shifting fish species that play vital roles in ecosystem connectivity, representing two distinct feeding guilds: mesopredators, specifically the gray snapper (Lutjanus griseus) and the bluestriped grunt (Haemulon sciurus), and herbivores, including the blue parrotfish (Scarus coeruleus), midnight parrotfish (Scarus coelestinus), and rainbow parrotfish (Scarus guacamaia). These species are known for their ontogenetic habitat shifts, moving from nearshore mangrove and seagrass nurseries to adult habitats on offshore reefs. By employing maximum entropy (MaxEnt) habitat suitability models, the study aimed to determine the primary spatial-environmental drivers of their habitat use and assess whether current management strategies effectively encompass these requirements. The findings indicate that while all five species share strong preferences for similar biogenic habitats, they also exhibit a surprising degree of spatial partitioning across the seascape, suggesting that shared traits such as feeding guild may not be sufficient to predict fine-scale habitat associations.
The coastal seascape of the Florida Keys is characterized as a mangrove-seagrass-reef continuum, a mosaic that provides essential shelter and foraging opportunities. However, escalating climatic and anthropogenic stressors are degrading these biogenic habitats and disrupting the vital movement pathways fishes use to transition across the shelf. Structural connectivity—the spatial arrangement of these habitats—is particularly important for fishes that depend on a series of environments to survive and mature. Existing management practices often target specific sites for protection or restoration, but these initiatives frequently lack explicit consideration of the connectivity needs across the full life cycle of these species. By quantifying where ecological movements occur and identifying the factors that drive them, the research team sought to provide actionable data for practitioners to better align site selection with the ecological needs of habitat-shifting fishes, thereby bolstering the resilience of reef ecosystems through improved management efficacy.
The researchers developed their habitat suitability models using a suite of 13 spatial-environmental predictors, which included benthic habitat type, seafloor morphology metrics, and interpolated abiotic water conditions. Occurrence records for the five focal species were sourced from two long-term monitoring programs coordinated by NOAA’s Southeast Fisheries Science Center, the South Florida Reef Visual Census and the Mangrove Visual Survey, covering the years 2014 through 2022. The models were specifically tuned using 10-fold cross-validation and rigorous feature selection to minimize overfitting and account for uneven sampling effort. Importantly, the study defined habitat suitability as the relative likelihood of diurnal occurrence for sub-adult individuals.
The model results identified benthic habitat type as the single most influential driver of species distribution, contributing an average of 40.2 percent to the permutation importance across the study. Patch reefs and aggregate reefs emerged as the most suitable habitats for all five focal species, highlighting their roles as critical stepping stones that link nearshore nursery grounds with the offshore barrier reef tract. This shared reliance suggests that patch reefs provide essential three-dimensional structure and resources in an otherwise lower-relief environment. For instance, while seafloor slopes greater than four degrees were generally suitable for all species, the suitability for the midnight parrotfish declined rapidly as slopes increased beyond fifteen degrees, illustrating that even widely suitable habitat types can have threshold-dependent utility.
A primary distinction in habitat use was observed between the two feeding guilds, with mesopredators showing a markedly stronger association with nearshore environments than their herbivorous counterparts. The gray snapper and bluestriped grunt are known for routine diel migrations, sheltering in structural-but-food-poor mangroves during the day and foraging in adjacent seagrass beds at night. This behavior likely drives their strong nearshore suitability signal. Conversely, the three parrotfish species demonstrated a higher affinity for the outer reef tract, which they use for foraging and growth as they transition to adult life stages. The rainbow parrotfish proved an exception among the herbivores, exhibiting a distinct suitability peak in mid-channel regions, which aligns with its preference for reefs located in closer proximity to nearshore nursery habitats. These guild-level differences reflect the underlying, species-specific ecological requirements that dictate how different fishes navigate the seascape during their ontogenetic development.
Beyond the guild-level differences, the study employed identity tests to quantify spatial overlap and environmental response similarity between pairs of species. These tests revealed that almost all pairs exhibit significantly less overlap than would be expected if species occurrences were randomized across the survey sites, providing clear evidence of spatial partitioning. This partitioning occurs even among species that share both their diet and their primary habitat type, such as the two grunt and snapper mesopredators. While the lowest overlap values were generally found between inter-feeding guild pairs, the lack of complete concordance within guilds indicates that species are likely partitioning space to minimize competition for food resources or to optimize survival in heterogeneous environments. This suggests that the spatial niche of a given species is shaped by a complex interplay of traits, of which feeding guild is only one component, necessitating a move beyond simple functional groupings in ecological modeling.
Evaluating the current management landscape, the research team overlaid the boundaries of four types of protection zones—Research-Only Areas, Sanctuary Preservation Areas, Wildlife Management Areas, and one Ecological Reserve—as well as restoration sites designated by the Mission: Iconic Reefs program, onto their suitability maps. The results showed that while all management zones had mean suitability values higher than the seascape-wide average, there was substantial variability. Restoration sites were consistently more suitable than protection zones, likely reflecting the deliberate selection of high-value sites by practitioners to maximize the return on restoration efforts. A critical finding from this evaluation is the underrepresentation of patch reefs in the current management regime. Despite being identified as a top-tier habitat for all five focal species, these crucial migratory stepping stones rarely fall within the boundaries of existing protection or restoration areas.
The discussion highlights that while the general agreement on habitat suitability across these species is a useful indicator for multi-species management, it may be partially an artifact of their shared ecological characteristics, such as being demersal, habitat-shifting, and reef-associated. The researchers noted several technical limitations that likely affected their findings. For instance, the 5-meter by 5-meter resolution of the bathymetric data used to derive structural complexity metrics may have resulted in a smoothing effect, potentially masking finer-scale features like crevices and overhangs that are essential for fish shelter. Furthermore, the use of seasonal means for temperature, salinity, and dissolved oxygen likely reduced variability in abiotic conditions, potentially leading to lower predictor importance for these variables unless conditions fell outside species’ specific physiological tolerances.
Looking toward future research, the study emphasizes that integrating information for a broader range of species, life stages, and functional groups will be necessary to estimate the overall value of coastal habitats comprehensively. The current models specifically focused on daytime habitat use for sub-adults, which does not account for nocturnal foraging or diel migrations. Integrating connectivity models with these habitat suitability outputs represents a promising avenue, as it would enable a more dynamic understanding of how fishes traverse these heterogeneous seascapes.
Ultimately, the study affirms that existing management zones are generally well-positioned relative to the needs of these five habitat-shifting fishes, but the intentional inclusion of connected habitat corridors is essential for long-term ecosystem health. Safeguarding continuous swaths of habitat that span the nearshore-to-offshore gradient is vital for maintaining the ecological processes that support ontogenetic shifts. By strategically protecting and restoring highly suitable patch reefs and maintaining connectivity, practitioners can leverage beneficial interactions between these fishes and their biogenic habitats. This research provides a data-driven framework that can help identify high-suitability hotspots, enabling management programs to move toward more effective, corridor-based strategies that protect the critical movement pathways defining and sustaining these vibrant coastal seascapes.
Subject of Research: Habitat suitability modeling and spatial partitioning of reef-associated fishes in the Florida Keys.
Article Title: Habitat-shifting predatory and herbivorous reef fishes exhibit spatial partitioning despite shared biophysical drivers of seascape use
Article References: Spence, I. N., Stuart, C. E., Wedding, L. M., Pittman, S. J., Serafy, J. E., Blondeau, J., & Green, S. J. (2026). Habitat-shifting predatory and herbivorous reef fishes exhibit spatial partitioning despite shared biophysical drivers of seascape use. Landscape Ecology, 41(11), Article 201. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10980-026-02456-2
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1007/s10980-026-02456-2
Keywords: Florida Keys, Reef Fish, Habitat Suitability, MaxEnt, Marine Ecology, Ontogenetic Shift, Spatial Partitioning, Connectivity, Seascape, Mesopredators, Herbivores, Patch Reefs, Environmental Modeling, Marine Management, Ecosystem Function, Coral Reefs, Fisheries Science, Biodiversity, Habitat Restoration, Biogenic Habitats

